Today something happened that I have not experienced in a long time. Four years to be exact.
One of my course-mates was giving out Christmas cards to our class, and she apologized very politely saying that she did not have one for me because she knew I did not celebrate Christmas and could not find a Hannukah card. This girl, being one of the nicest people I’ve ever met in my entire life, was sincere. And it’s true, I hadn’t seen so much as a dreidle in this country myself, never mind a Hannukah card. I told her not to worry about it, for it truly didn’t bother me.
The funny thing is that this used to happen to me all the time before I went to Brandeis. Everyone felt very awkward when it came to including me in the “Holiday” season celebrations, because as secular as they were, they were still Christmas celebrations.
Then, at Brandeis, being surrounded by Jews, and in such a community where all the gentiles at least were educated and comfortable with Judaism, this never came up! I’d get Hannukah cards from both Jews and Christians, and I’d get Christmas cards from both Jews and Christians. It didn’t really matter since we were all Jewish, or friends of Jews.
As an interesting juxtaposition, today I received a Christmas card in the mail from a good friend of mine from Brandeis. It was a Christmas card, and she is not Jewish, and she wrote: “Merry Christmas (Hannukah, whatever) and a Happy New Year!” And she knew it just simply didn’t matter.
If I think back to the girl I was in high school, it probably would have mattered to me. I was very sensitive to these issues, making it much harder for everyone around me to figure out how to include me. But at the time it seemed necessary, and looking back, I still maintain that it was important to stand my ground and force people to deal with the fact that some of us have different religious identities.
But now, having spent some time in a mostly Jewish community, I’m much more relaxed about my Jewish identity. But maybe part of that is just getting older, recognizing who I am, acknowledging my strengths and faults, and just being okay with it. I don’t have to define myself anymore, I can just be.
But this silly incident reminded me that I am no longer at Brandeis, and that I am, once again, inhabiting a gentile world. It will be interesting to see how this could change the sense of identity I developed in a Jewish community. Will it be something I have to defend again? Or can I just “be” even amongst the gentiles?







